The Hobbit [1978] (REGION 1) (NTSC)

Customer Reviews:

Good because of its feel, botched because of what it cut.......2007-11-02

This video is a good adaptiation of J. R. R. Tolkien's classic children's novel. There are many positive things to it. Yet there are also some negative aspects to it, because, after all, it is a human production.
The positive is it introduces the story to an audience that might not pick up a book, or people who have never heard of Tolkien (imagine that!). I can honestly say this movie is responsible for getting me into Tolkien. We had Disney, and I watched this and the sequel (Return of the King), although I remembered this the most. When I saw the book at a flea market back when I was 12 or 13, I bought it (I am now 20). Had it not been for this movie, I might have passed that book bye. Therefore, I'm heavily indebted to this movie, because it is responsible for my discovery of Tolkien. The animation, espically that of The Shire, is true to the stories. The depiction of Gollum is espically good, and that whole sequence is very well down. The animators and cast really capture the spirit of what Tolkien was trying to do. Gandalf is always a a delight. The dragon is magnificent (although they erroneously pronounce "Smaug" like the pollution "smog"). Much of the animation seems like pictures straight from Tolkien's sketch book.

The negative, although it is not surprising, tho' still disappointing, is they cut things out. The entire sequence with Beorn is cut out. It would have been very interesting to see him in this version. The elves do not have that `high elvish beauty' that so permeates THE LORD OF THE RINGS, and, to a lesser extent, THE HOBBIT. They are quite attrocious to look at. Strangely, they fit in well with the scenery and the animation style, but to the story it contradicts it. Some things are rushed over, most notable the episode with the Trolls. In the book, they have a fight o how to cook the dwarves, with Gandalf off scene, actually causing the fight. Here, they comment on how they like them, but there is no fight, and (unconvincingly) dawn overtakes them. On the mountain, although there is the thrush, there is no great ravens (Roac son of Carc). The entire political matter of the Arkenstone is left out. And for some strange reason, they change the number of how many live from 10 to 6. The reason why I could never understand. One scene I never understood was Bilbo, awakening to find the goblins upon them, but before dreaming, says "dwarves have a strange notion of perfection". It is only a 76 minute film, so they did cut things. It is sad they could not include more.

As you can tell, its chief weaknesses are the things it cut out. The movie is true to the book. Bilbo's physical appearance is now how I always visualize it, and Gollum is superb. He is blackened skinned in this, and green in THE RETURN OF THE KING. The animation is its strongest, and with exception to the Elves is true to Tolkien, the weakest is the things they were forced to cut. Overall, a good film. This place will always have special significance to me, because this is what got me into Tolkien. He, as MacDonald to Lewis, is my master.

Originally issued May 16, 2000 on Amazon.com

A good watch.......2004-03-28

This is a pleasant watch, and will be much enjoyed by children, as it shows the fantasy of Tolkien, in an easy and light hearted way. My children loved it, and still do.

Average customer rating:

So Very Comforting.

A true love story with a bit of spice

Breezy [1973] (NTSC) (REGION 1)
Starring: Norman Bartold , Lynn Borden , Richard Bull , Roger C. Carmel , and Johnnie Collins III
Director: Clint Eastwood
Manufacturer: Universal Studios
ProductGroup: DVD
Binding: DVD

All Drama | Drama | Categories | DVD | Video
All Children's DVD | Children's DVD | Categories | DVD | Video
Region 1 | Special Features | DVD | Video
DVD | Format (binding_browse-bin) | Refinements | DVD | Video
Similar Items:

The Chairman [1969] (REGION 1) (NTSC)

Satan Never Sleeps [1962] (REGION 1) (NTSC)

Bronco Billy [1980] (REGION 1) (NTSC)

Night Moves [1975] (REGION 1) (NTSC)

There Was a Crooked Man [1970] (REGION 1) (NTSC)

ASIN: B0001FVDK0
Release Date: 2004-06-01

Customer Reviews:

So Very Comforting........2007-07-25

A love affair between one initially un-willing professional, and one, open-minded, much more willing, lovely young hippie, wherein both change, both eventually find love, and both find the best in each other.
Lovely 1970's footage of architecture and clothes for the culturally-minded, and great dialogue in places, but it's the warmth, the pacing,the photography, and the gentleness which has made me love this film for years.
Do try it.

A true love story with a bit of spice.......2004-06-10

This is a hugely enjoyable old fashioned love story which would melt anyone's heart, convincingly acted throughout by its two leads. Despite the 'R' rating, there is no explicit sex, but we are treated on several occasions to a topless Kay Lenz and it's almost worth buying for that alone. For quite an old film, the transfer to DVD in widesceen format is first rate.

DVD:

DVD List

DVD