Average customer rating: |
The Ninth Gate [2000] (REGION 1) (NTSC)
Starring: Johnny Depp , Frank Langella , Lena Olin , Emmanuelle Seigner , and Barbara Jefford Director: Roman Polanski Manufacturer: Live/Artisan ProductGroup: DVD Binding: DVD Similar Items:
ASIN: 6305897786 Release Date: 2000-07-18 ![]() |
Amazon.co.uk Review
For a while it looks like Roman Polanski's The Ninth Gate, adapted from the novel The Club Dumas by Arturo Pérez-Reverte, might recapture the beautiful uneasiness of such masterpieces as Repulsion and Rosemary's Baby. The horror of a Roman Polanski picture is not about spectacle and shock but a goose-pimply sense of evil lurking just outside the frame and hidden behind the faces of slightly unsettling characters. Here, a calm, almost sleepy Johnny Depp plays cynical, unscrupulous rare-book hunter Dean Corso, who's hired by demonologist Boris Balkan (Frank Langella) to authenticate a rare volume that, legend has it, was co-written by Lucifer himself. Dean leaves a Gothic looking New York (re-created in Europe by Polanski as a sinister city of shadows) for Portugal and Paris to compare Balkan's volume with the two copies known to be in existence and uncovers a mystery with unholy ramifications. He also finds himself at the centre of a conspiracy that involves Balkan, a widow who will stop at nothing to retrieve Balkan's book (Lena Olin, who gleefully bites and claws her way through the part), and a mysterious guardian "angel" (Polanski's wife, Emmanuelle Seigner) who shadows his every step. The Ninth Gate is full of rumbling menace and deliciously unsettling imagery, but Polanski's languorous direction and purposefully vague story render a film that's eerie without every becoming thrilling. It's perpetually on the verge of becoming interesting--right up to its obscure final image.-Sean Axmaker, Amazon.comOn the DVD: Roman Polanski provides us with his first ever DVD commentary here, and makes his eye for detail and atmosphere very apparent in talking about design and his use of the camera. He also announces his love for the quality of DVD since he's always hated VHS. You also see him briefly amongst other interviewees in a two-minute featurette. There's also a trailer, 10 pages of production notes, and generous cast and crew information. One novelty is a gallery of The Nine Gates books' spot-the-difference satanic drawings. Best of all is an isolated track of Wojciech Kilar's excellent score, which is as well preserved by this transfer as the rich palette of earthy browns used by Polanski to paint the screen. --Paul Tonks
Amazon.co.uk Review
For a while it looks like Roman Polanski's The Ninth Gate, adapted from the novel The Club Dumas by Arturo Pérez-Reverte, might recapture the beautiful uneasiness of such masterpieces as Repulsion and Rosemary's Baby. The horror of a Roman Polanski picture is not about spectacle and shock but a goose-pimply sense of evil lurking just outside the frame and hidden behind the faces of slightly unsettling characters. Here, a calm, almost sleepy Johnny Depp plays cynical, unscrupulous rare-book hunter Dean Corso, who's hired by demonologist Boris Balkan (Frank Langella) to authenticate a rare volume that, legend has it, was co-written by Lucifer himself. Dean leaves a Gothic looking New York (re-created in Europe by Polanski as a sinister city of shadows) for Portugal and Paris to compare Balkan's volume with the two copies known to be in existence and uncovers a mystery with unholy ramifications. He also finds himself at the centre of a conspiracy that involves Balkan, a widow who will stop at nothing to retrieve Balkan's book (Lena Olin, who gleefully bites and claws her way through the part), and a mysterious guardian "angel" (Polanski's wife, Emmanuelle Seigner) who shadows his every step. The Ninth Gate is full of rumbling menace and deliciously unsettling imagery, but Polanski's languorous direction and purposefully vague story render a film that's eerie without every becoming thrilling. It's perpetually on the verge of becoming interesting--right up to its obscure final image.-Sean Axmaker, Amazon.comOn the DVD: Roman Polanski provides us with his first ever DVD commentary here, and makes his eye for detail and atmosphere very apparent in talking about design and his use of the camera. He also announces his love for the quality of DVD since he's always hated VHS. You also see him briefly amongst other interviewees in a two-minute featurette. There's also a trailer, 10 pages of production notes, and generous cast and crew information. One novelty is a gallery of The Nine Gates books' spot-the-difference satanic drawings. Best of all is an isolated track of Wojciech Kilar's excellent score, which is as well preserved by this transfer as the rich palette of earthy browns used by Polanski to paint the screen. --Paul Tonks
Customer Reviews:
Boffo! a good one.......2008-02-10
Smart and original adaptation of a great book.......2007-09-13
Mmm..........2006-11-16
a highly underrated thriller..........2006-08-06
A dumb attempt at making a clever movie........2005-10-03
The plot line unfolds very slowly which is not necessarily a bad thing however the plot is so tedious and unoriginal that the movie seemed to drag on for hours. There are no suprises or twists along the way, the film just follows Johnny Depp as he wanders from place to place from one shallow character to another with the occasional dull murder or 'enigmatic' clue thrown in. The worst thing about this movie is it keeps promising more and then not delivering. I would have switched it off very quickly only I kept expecting some twist or revelation to be revealed which kept me watching. Aparently it's based on some historical fact about a satanic book which would have been quite interesting had any of the history actually been explained.
Johnny Depp is blank and nearly characterless in this movie, I felt no empathy, good or bad with him at all. However he comes out looking quite good compared to everyone else. The characters seem to have all been drawn from a comic book and then had the life drained out of them. There's no passion or anything believable in any of it.
I don't know what people saw in this movie that made them think the colours and sets and atmosphere were so good. I thought it was shot in a very average way with no imagination put into the use of cameras or lighting. Some of the sets were nice (especially that old house with the bell pull) but the camera movements were so mundane that they never took full advantage of them. This is the most washed out film-noir I've ever seen.
It appears during the film that the film maker is building up some intricate puzzle involving the different books however this turns out not to be true. The solution to the puzzle is never revealed because the film maker didn't even have the imagination to think up an interesting puzzle in the first place. There's also some dreadful gaping plotholes such as why does Boris Balkan bother to employ Johnny Depp when he just goes and steals the other books himself anyway ?
The ending isn't really all that mysterious, it's just a bit ambiguous. I actually quite like an enigmatic ending to a movie if it is used properly. Some of the most profound and philisophical movies have endings that leave you hanging however here it's just used to hide the end of the plot (probably because it's awful). There are a few possible theories as to what happens at the end but none of them are very interesting. There are no secrets hidden in this movie.
In conclusion I have to say that this is one of worst movies I've seen in a long time. I'm frustrated that I wasted two and a half hours watching it (although at least I've gained some pleasure from lampooning it !)
I believe that if you find this is a clever, subtle or profound movie then you are clearly staring at the emperors new clothes !(Unless of course there are in fact three slightly different versions of this movie and its secret is only revealed when you compare them together !)
Average customer rating: |
Stir of Echoes/The Ninth Gate [2000] (REGION 1) (NTSC)
Starring: Johnny Depp , Frank Langella , Lena Olin , Emmanuelle Seigner , and Barbara Jefford Director: Roman Polanski , and David Koepp Manufacturer: Live/Artisan ProductGroup: DVD Binding: DVD ASIN: B00005NX13 Release Date: 2004-10-19 ![]() |
UK DVD: