Average customer rating:
|
The Killing of Sister George [1968] (REGION 1) (NTSC)
Starring: Beryl Reid , Susannah York , Coral Browne , Ronald Fraser , and Patricia Medina Director: Robert Aldrich Manufacturer: MGM ProductGroup: DVD Binding: DVD Similar Items:
ASIN: B0009X7BGY Release Date: 2005-08-23 ![]() |
Amazon.co.uk Review
"Sister George" within The Killing of Sister George is Britain's best-loved soap opera character, played by actress June Buckeridge (Beryl Reid). Buckeridge has become so identified with her character--a sweet old Miss Marple-ish nurse who putters around her quaint little village on a motor scooter--even her friends call her George. But outside the studio she's a hard-drinking, hot-tempered, foul-mouthed lesbian living with an immature young thing she's nicknamed "Childie" (Susannah York, who makes her memorable entrance in a sheer baby-doll nightie). At her worst Sister George is an abusive monster (in a moment of rage she forces Childie to eat the butt of her cigar) but beneath the bluster is an insecure television actress. When the studio decides to kill her character off and an executive makes a play for Childie, the soap star desperately clings to her young lover. Director Robert Aldrich, best known for his tough action films and gothic thrillers, brings his fierce vision of human nature to Frank Marcus's play . In its best moments the film simmers in angry suspicion and helpless frustration, brought to life by Reid's vivacious performance but other scenes are overlong and stage-bound and would have benefited greatly from judicious trimming and tightening. The caricatured portrayals of lesbian life have aged rather poorly--an inevitable sign of the times--but this acidic show-biz drama still carries a hefty emotional punch. --Sean Axmaker, Amazon.comCustomer Reviews:
Groundbreaking!.......2006-10-14
Beryl Reid's finest hour.......2006-05-16
Moooooooo.......2004-11-17
BERYLLIANT !!.......2004-08-02
Messrs. Reid, York and Browne turn out superlative performances, and Beryl Reid as the lead gets my vote as one of the best screen portrayals of all time. Certainly it is hard to sympathise with Reid's character (June Buckridge/Sister George), but you have to be dead from the feet up not to be moved by the heart-rending finale, largely brought about by her own inability to cope with the break-up of her world and, it has to be said, her self induced destruction.
George's language is quite strong at times, and the one sex scene has us sharing Mrs. Croft's (Coral Browne) dry throat and pounding heart as she gives way to her awakening sexuality. Only the depiction of the lesbian club looks really dated but, hey, it WAS nearly 40 years ago, and all the spot-on dialogue and situations could just as well happen today (and probably do within many a relationship, gay or otherwise) and stand up well!
Previous reviewers have rather missed the point, focusing on the relatively unimportant role stereotyping (butch v pretty) and the heavy make-up typical of the era, the fact being that this is not a "pretty" film, and wasn't meant to be; hopefully, anyone having read them has given it a chance anyway, and been glad they did.
The DVD is crisp and clear, and the lack of extras (inevitable in a film of this age), though regretable, does not detract. A "must have" for anyone genuinely interested in character acting at it's best, and one that transcends time.
Disappointing.......2003-08-12
Average customer rating: |
Der Fan [1982]
Starring: Désirée Nosbusch , Bodo Steiger , Simone Brahmann , Jonas Vischer , and Helga Tölle Director: Eckhart Schmidt Manufacturer: Oracle Home Entertainment Limited ProductGroup: DVD Binding: DVD Similar Items:
ASIN: B00023JHDG Release Date: 2004-06-21 ![]() |
UK DVD: